Florida Chief Financial Officer Alex Sink/Department of Financial Services Florida from space/NASA Florida beach scene Florida palm tree Florida surf

Return to Senior Resource Center Home Page

Filing A Claim On Your Homeowner’s Policy

By Jane L. Lyon

Many Floridians experience a great deal of stress when thinking about and dealing with their homeowner’s insurance.  This article is an overview of what may happen when a claim is filed.

Smooth Claims Process on the dwelling: 

Take photos or a video of the damage, if possible, have two copies: one for you and the second for the insurance company.

When a claim is filed, the insurance company will assign an Adjustor.  The Adjustor may work exclusively for your insurance company, or, may contract with several companies, or may be self-employed.  All Adjustors must be licensed in the state of Florida.  Check to see if an adjustor is licensed by calling the Department of Financial Services Consumer Helpline, 1-800-342-2762.

Policyholders can also hire a Public Adjustor to review and negotiate claims with the insurance company on behalf of the policyholder.  Public Adjustors charge the policyholder a percentage of the claim settlement amount the policyholder will receive. Public Adjusters must also be licensed. They cannot charge more than the amount stated on the contract and cannot charge up front for their services.

The Adjustor has the authority to inspect the damage and write an estimate of the cost of the claim.  Some adjustors have the authority to issue checks.  If they do not have check-writing authority, then they send the estimate to the insurance company who will issue the check.

Most checks will state that acceptance or cashing of the check is considered payment in full.  However, if the damage is greater than initially estimated, supplemental claims can be filed. To file a supplemental claim, the policyholder must have estimates from licensed contractors to verify the additional costs.

REPAIR WORK:

Many types of repairmen/contractors may approach seniors.  If you are approached by someone claiming to be from a public utility company (electric company, gas company), ask for their identification and look for their repair truck. If you are still note sure, call the utility company using the number in your local phone book to verify that crews are working in your area.  

If other types of repairs are necessary, it is important to keep the following things in mind.  Contractors work for YOU.  You need to interview them and ask questions like:  How long have you been in business?  Are you licensed and registered with the state?  Do you have workers compensation insurance (ask for proof). How many projects like mine have you completed in the last 12 months?  Will my project require a permit?  Will you be using subcontractors? Can I contact one of your previous customers?

Check on the contractor’s address, license and complaint history by calling your city or county building department, or by checking with the Department of Business and Professional Regulation, 850-487-1395 or www.state.fl.us/dbpr.

Ask for their business card and license number as well as proof of worker’s compensation and liability insurance for the contractor and subcontractor.  This is an important protection for you, so that attempts to file for any injuries are not filed under your property insurance.

Obtain at least three bids/estimates or quotes.  When comparing these, keep in mind the type and quality of materials each bid lists.  Remember that the lowest bid may not always be the best bid.  Also make sure that the repairs being made will be up to the current city or county codes.

Find out what type of mitigation discounts your homeowner policy offers.  A mitigation discount is a discount insurance companies offer policyholders to include wind-resistant building materials in the structure. These may provide you with a discount on your homeowner’s policy premium. More importantly, they will protect your home from extensive damage and provide a secure place for you in the event of a storm.

NEVER agree to file or “pull” the work permit yourself.  The repair company should be able to do this, it is their responsibility and if you file for it, you may become responsible for any code violations, fines and/or penalties.

Make sure that inspections are done and that a final inspection is passed on the job.  The contract should be clear on the responsibility of these inspections.

Look out for any other necessary expenses not specified in the contract, like permits, inspections, electricians, architects, or changes to plan designs.  Be very clear on what is included in the contract and what you are expected to pay.

Read and keep a copy of the contract that should be signed by you and the contractor.  NEVER SIGN A BLANK CONTRACT.  Make sure that everything you have agreed upon is listed in the signed copy of the contract as well as the warranty and the beginning and end date and any penalties or discounts for delays.

Make sure that there are no liens placed on your property regarding this work, if there are, get the final release when you make the final payment.

PAYMENTS:  AVOID PAYING UP FRONT. DO NOT PROVIDE ANY PAYMENT WITHOUT A SIGNED CONTRACT IN HAND. A company might request a down payment; this should be no more than one –third of the total estimated cost, but no one should pay any money without a signed contract.  It is extremely important that licensed, reputable businesses and/or individuals are hired for repairs; preferably those who are local and can provide you with references.  DO NOT PAY CASH, AND OBTAIN RECEIPTS.  Low interest loans are available to storm victims through the Small Business Administration, visit their web site at www.sba.gov.

Contractors should provide a pay schedule as work progresses and itemized prices for the work.

Do not make the final payment until the final county/city/state inspections AND until you are satisfied with the work, this includes all clean-up.

Be wary of any contractor who refers you to someone they know who can help you get the money.  This could be part of a home improvement loan scam and could result in your losing your home.

 Possible issues with claim processing: 

The 2004 Hurricane Season was unprecedented and as such several problems arose for homeowners filing claims.  It is important to note that at any time in this process consumers are encouraged to contact the Florida Department of Financial Services.  This Department can be reached through the toll free statewide helpline at 1-800-342-2762, or through our web site:  myfloridacfo.com. 

Adjustors:  If the adjustor does not contact the consumer, the consumer can contact the insurance company. 

Estimate Disputes: 

(1)   If the adjustor provides a lower estimate than the contractor, try to obtain three estimates, submit them to the insurance company to validate the dispute.  Maintain copies and records of contact made with the insurance company.

(2)   If the insurance company does not respond, or does not honor the request for the higher bid, contact the Florida Department of Financial Services.  Your options may include a mediation hearing at no cost to you.

 Delayed Payment:  If the consumer and the insurance company comes to an agreement, but the insurance company is delaying payment, the consumer should contact the insurance company, and if possible, document the details of the call.  If this does not result in any action, contact the Florida Department of Financial Services. 

 Lost Files:  Many consumers reported that the insurance company and/or the adjustors lost their files.  If possible, the consumer should keep their own records regarding meetings with adjustors and/or other insurance representatives.  If copies can be obtained of any related documents, this should be done as well.

 Property Disputes:

Inventory Disputes:  Consumers frequently complained that their insurance would not cover certain items, or disputed their value.  Options to prevent this include documenting contents with photo’s or a video.  (It’s important to have the video stored somewhere other than the consumer’s home).  If there are unique or hard to replace items, consumers should obtain written estimates on their value.  Note that some policies may require additional coverage, or endorsements on items such as antiques, jewelry, furs and electronics.

Additional Structures:  It is important to confirm whether the policy covers any additional structures on the property.  These include tool sheds, detached garages, small boats, fences and pool cages.  There have been numerous disputes over these as a result of the 2004 hurricanes.

Condominium Disputes:  It is to the policyholder’s benefit to make sure that their Condominium Documents have been updated in accordance to Florida state laws.  It is equally important to understand the responsibility of the unit owner and the responsibility of the association in the event of a disaster.  If there is a dispute, contact the Consumer Services Helpline. 

Consumer Options:

Consumer Services Helpline:  This Helpline is staffed by Consumer Services Specialists who can answer questions and provide resources for additional assistance.  The number is 1-800-342-2762.

Florida Department of Financial Services web site myfloridacfo.com has useful information for consumers.

Mediation:  Mediation is a process where a court certified mediator meets with the consumer and a representative from the insurance company.  The purpose is to reach an agreement both parties can accept.  The mediator helps the parties focus on the issues and understand each other’s point of view, but does not dictate the outcome of the discussion.  Certain factors must be present to qualify for mediation.  To determine if mediation is an alternative, consumers are encouraged to call the Consumer Services Helpline.

The Department of Financial Services stands ready to help consumers who have questions or, are having problems with their insurance company.  The department urges all consumers to check and update their coverage at least annually and to call the Consumer Services Helpline with any questions.

 Please call the Florida Department of Financial Services’ toll-free helpline or visit our web site with insurance or financial inquiries,  (800) 342-2762 or myfloridacfo.com

Note: Jane Lyon is the Regional Manager of the Consumer Services, Florida DFS.  For additional information or to request a speaker for your organization, please contact the local office at (727) 587-7260.